Homemade Eggnog Recipe (2024)

This site contains affiliate links to products we recommend. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

• PostedJune 18, 2022
• inBeverages, Cook

Learn to make eggnog any time of year and enjoy this treat just like Pa from Farmer Boy. You can sip on this sweet treat to keep you going all day long.

While reading Farmer Boy by Laura Ingalls Wilder I came across the part where Pa is working out in a really hot hayfield. He says that a man can get more done in his twelve hours of the day if he has all the eggnog he can drink morning and evening.

I thought, eggnog? During the summer and not at Christmastime? That sounds delicious!

Since we have all the eggs we can handle right now I thought this would be a great time to try it. If you find yourself in the same situation, first learn how to safely handle farm fresh eggs.

Then, see the many ways to use up excess eggs here, how to water-glass and preserve fresh eggs here, how to freeze eggs here, how to freeze-dry eggs here, how to pickle eggs here, and how to make homemade egg noodles here.

We also have a tutorial for making aged eggnog just like George Washington used to make (This is an alcoholic version of eggnog).

If you’d like to get eight different egg preservation methods you can grab our FREE downloadable booklet here.

Homemade Eggnog

I don’t have an eggnog recipe of my own, so I went straight away to The Little House Cookbook and sure enough, there is a recipe for non-alcoholic eggnog.

I did make some slight alterations of my own to make it more suitable to our liking. Feel free to play with the recipe below to make it your own!

Eggnog Ingredients

• Eggs – It’s best to use eggs you trust in this recipe. We have a surplus of farm-fresh eggs during the summer months, which makes this the perfect way to use them up! I wouldn’t recommend making this with store-bought eggs, but fresh from the farm!
• Sweetener – The original recipe in The Little House Cookbook called for 1/2 cup sugar, but we adjusted that to 1/4 cup maple syrup and found it was perfectly sweet.
• Milk & Cream – This is where you can play with the ratios to make it exactly how you like. If you want it thicker, more reminiscent of store-bought eggnog, then use all heavy cream. If you want to omit the cream and keep it lower in fat, use all milk. We found the recipe below to be a perfect consistency and richness.
• Nutmeg – Fresh grated nutmeg will add the best flavor. Feel free to add in any additional spices you like such as cinnamon, ground ginger, cardamom, etc.

How to Make Eggnog

1. The first step is to separate the eggs into two bowls. One bowl for yolks, one for whites.
2. Into the bowl of egg yolks, add maple syrup, milk and cream. Blend well using an immersion blender.
3. With a clean immersion blender (or a whisk attachment), whip egg whites until soft peaks form. I like to add a pinch of cream of tartar because this helps the whites whip up faster and hold the peaks better.
4. Gently fold the egg whites into the eggnog mixture until it’s all incorporated.
5. Grate fresh nutmeg over the top of the bowl, ladle into a glass, and top with more freshly grated nutmeg.
6. Enjoy!

Making eggnog couldn’t be easier. There’s no reason we can’t enjoy this delicious treat any time of year. To make it refreshing on a hot summer day, pour the eggnog over ice. For a warm treat in the winter, gently warm it on the stovetop until steaming (but not boiling).

Did you make this recipe? If you made this recipe, we’d love for you to leave a star rating on the recipe card below. Then snap a photo and tag us on social media so we can see!

More Posts You May Enjoy

• Homemade Switchel
• How to Make Caramel Apples
• Pumpkin Fruit Leather Recipe
• How to Make a Wreath
• Enjoying Stress-Free Holidays
• DIY Christmas Garland
• Freeze Dried Ice Cream
• Instant Herbal Iced Tea (Instant Cold Brew)
• Homemade Natural Water Flavoring
• Homemade Kombucha – A Healthy Summer Drink
• Cherry Almond Flavored Kombucha (How to Second Ferment Kombucha)

More to Explore